Interview scorecard
Chief of Staff
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
Strategic thinking
Connects company goals to the few priorities that matter most and explains the trade-offs behind them.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you helped leaders choose between competing priorities. How did you decide?
- Describe a goal you traced back to the company's bigger aims. What did you change as a result?
- Tell me about a plan that stopped making sense. How did you notice and what did you do?
1: Below the bar
Lists tasks without linking them to company goals. Can't explain why one priority outranked another.
3: Meets the bar
Links work to company goals and picks sensible priorities. Names trade-offs but rarely looks at longer-term effects or changing conditions.
5: Above the bar
Frames choices around company goals, weighs options unprompted, and flags long-term risks. Explains how they spotted when the plan needed to change.
Cross-team coordination
Aligns teams with competing priorities so shared work moves forward without the leader stepping in.
Questions
- Tell me about a time two teams wanted conflicting things. How did you get them aligned?
- Describe a time you needed help from a team that didn't report to you.
- Tell me about a handoff between teams that went wrong. What did you change afterward?
1: Below the bar
Relies on the executive or formal authority to settle conflicts. Blames other teams when work stalls.
3: Meets the bar
Brings teams together and gets agreement on next steps. Understands each side's goals but follows up only when things slip.
5: Above the bar
Learns each team's incentives first, finds a shared outcome, and sets up lasting routines that keep teams aligned without escalation.
Project management
Drives multi-step initiatives to completion by setting scope, owners, deadlines, and tracking progress.
Questions
- Tell me about a project you ran from kickoff to finish. How did you plan it?
- Describe a time a project slipped off schedule. What did you do?
- How do you track many projects at once and decide what gets attention?
1: Below the bar
Describes tasks without a plan, owners, or dates. Learns of delays late and reacts without adjusting scope.
3: Meets the bar
Sets clear owners and deadlines and checks progress regularly. Handles a slip by adjusting the plan, sometimes late.
5: Above the bar
Defines scope and success upfront, spots risks early, and adjusts plans before deadlines slip. Uses a simple system across projects.
Discretion
Protects sensitive information and handles confidential matters with sound judgment about what to share and with whom.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you held confidential information others wanted. How did you handle it?
- Describe a time you had to decide whether to share sensitive information. What guided you?
- Tell me about a time you made a mistake with sensitive information. What did you do afterward?
1: Below the bar
Shares sensitive details casually or sees no problem doing so. Can't describe a rule for deciding what to share.
3: Meets the bar
Keeps confidences and checks before sharing. Explains a clear reason for what they shared, though handles gray areas cautiously or stiffly.
5: Above the bar
Sets boundaries early, shares only what each person needs, and owns past slips. Declines pressure politely while keeping trust.
Problem solving
Defines messy problems clearly, weighs options, and drives a chosen fix to a result.
Questions
- Tell me about a messy problem nobody owned. How did you figure out what was wrong?
- Describe a time your first fix failed. What did you do next?
- Tell me about a problem where you had to choose between imperfect options. How did you decide?
1: Below the bar
Describes symptoms, not causes. Applies the first fix that comes to mind and can't say why it worked or didn't.
3: Meets the bar
Finds the likely cause, compares a few options, and fixes it. Explains the choice but checks the result only loosely.
5: Above the bar
Defines the real problem first, tests options quickly, adjusts when wrong, and shows the fix held and what changed afterward.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.