Free tool
Interview scorecard maker
Enter a role and 3–6 skills to create a scorecard with clear examples for each skill's rating scale. Give every interviewer the same criteria, ready to print or share.
1 · Below the bar
3 · Meets the bar
5 · Above the bar
How to use a scorecard in a panel interview
Agree on what you're looking for before the interview, then use the scorecard to guide your discussion afterward.
-
Agree on the skills first
Choose the skills that matter most for the role. Review the scoring examples together so everyone knows what to look for in a candidate's answers.
-
Use the same scorecard
Give each interviewer a copy with the same skills and scoring examples. Use it for every candidate applying for the role so you have a consistent basis for comparison.
-
Score before you discuss
Write down your ratings while the interview is fresh, before comparing notes with the team. Include examples from the candidate's answers to explain your scores.
-
Compare scores and talk through differences
Look at the ratings side by side. If you disagree, discuss the answers behind each score. Use that evidence to decide whether the candidate meets the role's requirements.
Frequently asked questions
What is an interview scorecard?
An interview scorecard is a form for rating candidates against the skills a role needs. It gives interviewers a shared set of criteria, a rating scale, and space for notes, making feedback easier to compare across the hiring team.
How many skills should an interview scorecard include?
This tool lets you choose 3–6 skills. Focus on the ones that matter most for the role and that you can meaningfully assess during the interview. If you need to cover more, spread them across separate interview rounds.
How do you score an interview from 1 to 5?
Rate each skill using the examples on your scorecard. This tool provides descriptions for scores of 1, 3, and 5, with 2 and 4 available for answers that fall between them. Add a brief note about what the candidate said to support each rating. If you didn't cover a skill, leave it unscored.
What is a behavioural anchor?
A behavioural anchor is a written example of what a particular score looks like in practice. For problem solving, a score of 3 might describe someone who explains a workable solution, while a 5 might also include how they weighed alternatives and checked the result. These examples help interviewers explain and compare their ratings.
Is an interview scorecard the same as an interview evaluation form?
The terms are often used interchangeably. Both help you record and assess a candidate's interview. The format matters more than the name: look for clear criteria, a defined rating scale, and room to explain your scores.
Is the interview scorecard maker free?
Yes. You can create a scorecard without signing up, then print it, save it as a PDF, or share it by link.
Keep every interviewer's
feedback in one place
With PontaHR, your team fills out scorecards on the candidate's profile. Compare ratings and feedback side by side when it's time to decide.
See how scorecards work in PontaHR, then try it with a guided free trial.