Interview scorecard
Customer Success Manager
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
Relationship building
Builds trust with customer contacts and keeps those relationships strong through good and difficult moments.
Questions
- Tell me about a customer relationship you built from scratch. What did you do first?
- Tell me about a time you delivered bad news to a customer. What happened next?
- How have you kept in touch with a customer who went quiet?
1: Below the bar
Describes relationships as answering requests. Contacts customers only when something is wrong and has no plan for building trust.
3: Meets the bar
Keeps regular contact with main customer contacts and handles bad news honestly. Relies mostly on one contact per account.
5: Above the bar
Builds ties with several people per account, shares bad news early, and gives examples of customers who stayed loyal because of it.
Onboarding
Guides new customers from signup to first real value through a clear, agreed plan.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you onboarded a new customer. How did you plan it?
- Describe a customer who stalled during setup. What did you do to restart progress?
- How do you decide that onboarding is finished and a customer is ready to run alone?
1: Below the bar
Sends generic setup guides and waits for questions. Cannot say what success looks like for the customer or when onboarding ends.
3: Meets the bar
Follows a standard plan with set steps and dates. Checks in when progress slows and defines a clear finish point.
5: Above the bar
Agrees the customer's goal first, adapts the plan to them, spots stalls early, and measures first value before handing over.
Renewals and expansion
Spots renewal risk early and finds growth opportunities that fit what each customer needs.
Questions
- Tell me about a renewal you were worried about. What did you do?
- Tell me about a time you grew a customer's spend. How did you spot the chance?
- How do you decide when to raise an upsell and when to wait?
1: Below the bar
Waits for the renewal date to act. Treats expansion as pushing extra products without linking them to customer needs.
3: Meets the bar
Tracks renewal dates and some warning signs. Proposes expansion tied to a stated need, but timing and follow-through are inconsistent.
5: Above the bar
Spots risk months ahead and acts on it. Ties expansion to the customer's goals, with clear examples of results and timing.
Product knowledge
Explains what the product does and how customers use it to reach their goals.
Questions
- Tell me about a product you supported. How did you learn it well enough to teach it?
- Describe a time you matched a customer's goal to a feature they weren't using.
- Tell me about a time you didn't know an answer about the product. What did you do?
1: Below the bar
Lists features without linking them to customer goals. Gives vague answers and doesn't say how they'd find out more.
3: Meets the bar
Explains main features clearly and links some to customer goals. Knows who to ask when a question goes beyond them.
5: Above the bar
Ties features to specific customer outcomes, spots unused features that help, and shares what they learn with the team.
Problem solving
Finds the root cause of a customer issue and drives it to a lasting fix.
Questions
- Tell me about a customer problem with no obvious cause. How did you work it out?
- Describe a time a fix didn't work. What did you do next?
- Tell me about a recurring customer issue you stopped for good. How?
1: Below the bar
Passes problems to others or applies quick fixes. Doesn't ask why it happened or check the customer's issue is resolved.
3: Meets the bar
Gathers facts, finds a likely cause and fixes the customer's issue. Follows up, but seldom prevents it happening again.
5: Above the bar
Tests several causes, involves the right people and keeps the customer informed. Fixes the root cause and prevents repeats.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.