Interview scorecard
Engineering Manager
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
People management
Coaches engineers toward growth and handles performance problems directly and fairly.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you helped someone on your team grow into a bigger role.
- Describe a time you gave hard feedback to an underperforming engineer. What happened?
- Tell me about a time two people on your team disagreed. What did you do?
1: Below the bar
Gives vague examples with no specific feedback. Avoids hard conversations or blames the person without looking at their own part.
3: Meets the bar
Gives concrete examples of feedback and coaching. Addresses problems fairly, though late or with limited follow-up on results.
5: Above the bar
Gives specific, timely feedback tailored to each person. Describes clear outcomes, what they learned, and what they changed afterward.
Delivery
Gets the team to ship planned work on time by managing scope, risk and progress.
Questions
- Tell me about a project that slipped. When did you notice, and what did you do?
- Tell me about a time you cut scope to hit a date. How did you decide?
- How do you keep track of progress across the team without slowing people down?
1: Below the bar
Blames outside causes for delays. Learns of problems late and has no clear method for tracking progress or risk.
3: Meets the bar
Describes a regular tracking routine and spots most slips in time. Adjusts scope or dates but reacts more than plans ahead.
5: Above the bar
Names risks early, trades scope against dates with clear reasons, and shares changes before they bite. Reviews misses to improve the process.
Technical judgment
Weighs technical options and risks well enough to guide the team's decisions without doing the engineering themselves.
Questions
- Tell me about a technical decision your team disagreed on. How did you help settle it?
- Describe a time you stepped in or held back on a technical call. Why?
- Tell me about a technical risk you spotted early. What did you do about it?
1: Below the bar
Defers every technical call to engineers or overrules them without reasons. Can't explain the trade-offs in their own examples.
3: Meets the bar
Asks useful questions and explains the main trade-offs in a past decision. Sometimes needs an engineer to judge the risks.
5: Above the bar
Frames options and risks clearly, knows when to decide or delegate, and explains how a past call played out.
Hiring
Builds a strong team by defining the need, assessing candidates fairly, and closing the right people.
Questions
- Tell me about a role you hired for. How did you decide what you needed?
- Tell me about a hiring decision you got wrong. What did you change afterward?
- How do you keep your interviews fair across candidates? Give a real example.
1: Below the bar
Hires on gut feel or similarity to themselves. Has no clear criteria and can't say what they learned from past hires.
3: Meets the bar
Defines the role and uses set questions with a panel. Can describe a past misjudgment and one change they made.
5: Above the bar
Writes clear criteria first, scores candidates against them, and checks bias. Shows how past misses changed their process and results.
Stakeholder management
Aligns non-engineering partners on priorities and trade-offs, and keeps them informed so surprises are rare.
Questions
- Tell me about a time a stakeholder wanted something your team couldn't deliver. What did you do?
- Describe how you keep stakeholders informed about progress and risks on a project.
- Tell me about a time two stakeholders wanted conflicting things from your team. How did it end?
1: Below the bar
Says yes to everything or avoids the conversation. Stakeholders hear about problems late, and the candidate blames them for conflicts.
3: Meets the bar
Explains limits clearly and gives regular updates. Handles conflicts by escalating or splitting the difference, with limited effort to understand the partner's goals.
5: Above the bar
Asks about the underlying goal, offers options with costs, and warns early of risks. Resolves conflicts directly and keeps the partners' trust.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.