Interview scorecard
Project Manager
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
Planning
Turns a goal into a realistic schedule with clear tasks, owners, dates and dependencies.
Questions
- Tell me about a project you planned from scratch. How did you build the schedule?
- How do you estimate how long tasks will take, and who do you ask?
- Tell me about a plan that went off track. What did you change?
1: Below the bar
Gives a vague plan with few dates or owners. Estimates are guesses and the plan never changes once made.
3: Meets the bar
Breaks work into tasks with owners and dates. Checks estimates with the team and updates the plan when things slip.
5: Above the bar
Maps dependencies and sets milestones, tests estimates against past projects, and adjusts the plan early with the team when slips appear.
Risk management
Spots threats to a project early and acts to reduce their likelihood or impact.
Questions
- Tell me about a risk you spotted before it became a problem. What did you do?
- Tell me about a risk that hit your project anyway. How did you respond?
- How do you decide which risks deserve your time, and how do you track them?
1: Below the bar
Only reacts once problems appear. Can't give an example of a risk spotted early or explain how they track risks.
3: Meets the bar
Names real risks and a plan for each, and tracks them regularly. Ranking by impact is basic, and fallback plans are sometimes missing.
5: Above the bar
Spots risks early, ranks them by likelihood and impact, and agrees owners and fallback plans. Shares what they learned from past misses.
Stakeholder management
Builds trust with people who have competing interests and keeps them informed, aligned and willing to decide.
Questions
- Tell me about a time two stakeholders wanted opposite things from your project. What did you do?
- Describe how you keep busy senior stakeholders informed without overloading them.
- Tell me about a time you had to say no to a stakeholder. How did it go?
1: Below the bar
Treats all stakeholders alike or avoids conflict. Updates only when asked, and blames others when relationships go wrong.
3: Meets the bar
Identifies key stakeholders and gives regular updates. Handles a disagreement by talking it through, though mostly after it has surfaced.
5: Above the bar
Maps stakeholders early, tailors updates to each, and settles conflicts by agreeing trade-offs. Says no clearly and keeps the relationship intact.
Organization
Keeps tasks, documents and deadlines in order so the team always knows what to do next.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you juggled several projects at once. How did you keep track?
- Describe how you keep project documents and decisions easy for others to find.
- Tell me about a time things got messy. How did you restore order?
1: Below the bar
Relies on memory or scattered notes. Gives examples of missed details or teammates unsure where to find things.
3: Meets the bar
Uses a consistent system such as task lists or a shared folder. Occasionally falls behind but recovers and keeps others informed.
5: Above the bar
Describes a clear, repeatable system that others adopt. Spots slipping details early, and teammates can find anything without asking.
Problem solving
Diagnoses project obstacles, weighs options, and picks a fix that gets work moving again.
Questions
- Tell me about a project problem you hadn't seen coming. How did you work out the cause?
- Describe a time you had two possible fixes. How did you choose between them?
- Tell me about a fix that didn't work. What did you do next?
1: Below the bar
Describes the symptom but not the cause. Waits for others to decide, or tries one fix without checking it worked.
3: Meets the bar
Finds the likely cause, considers a couple of options, and picks one with a reason. Checks the result afterward.
5: Above the bar
Gathers facts to find the real cause, compares options by cost and impact, adjusts when it fails, and shares what was learned.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.