Interview scorecard
Sales Manager
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
Coaching
Helps sales reps improve their results through feedback, observation, and regular one-on-one conversations.
Questions
- Tell me about a rep you helped improve. What did you do first?
- Describe a time you gave a rep hard feedback. How did they respond?
- How do you decide which rep to coach and what to work on?
1: Below the bar
Gives general advice or takes over the rep's deals. Can't describe a specific change a rep made.
3: Meets the bar
Describes regular one-on-ones and specific feedback. Names a rep who improved, but links it loosely to their coaching.
5: Above the bar
Watches real calls, picks one skill per rep, sets follow-ups, and shows measurable improvement tied to their coaching.
Forecasting
Predicts team revenue accurately and explains the evidence behind each number to leadership.
Questions
- Tell me about a quarter where your forecast missed. What did you learn?
- How do you decide which deals go into your commit number?
- Tell me about a time you changed a forecast mid-quarter. What triggered it?
1: Below the bar
Relies on rep gut feel or hope. Can't say why deals were in the number or why a miss happened.
3: Meets the bar
Uses clear stage criteria and checks deals with reps. Explains most misses but adjusts the number late.
5: Above the bar
Tests each deal against buyer evidence, tracks past accuracy, and flags risks early with a revised number and reasons.
Pipeline management
Keeps the team's pipeline healthy by reviewing stages regularly, removing stalled deals, and spotting coverage gaps early.
Questions
- Tell me about a time your team's pipeline looked thin. What did you do?
- How do you decide which deals stay in the pipeline and which come out?
- Describe how you review pipeline with your team each week. What do you look for?
1: Below the bar
Reviews pipeline only when a number is missed. Leaves stale deals in and can't say what makes a deal qualified.
3: Meets the bar
Reviews pipeline weekly with clear stage rules. Removes stalled deals and acts on gaps, though often after they appear.
5: Above the bar
Sets clear stage criteria, cleans out stalled deals routinely, and spots coverage gaps weeks ahead with specific actions taken.
Hiring
Identifies, evaluates, and selects sales candidates who fit the team's needs, using a consistent and fair process.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you hired a salesperson. How did you decide what to look for?
- Describe an interview question you rely on. What does a strong answer tell you?
- Tell me about a hire that didn't work out. What would you change in your process?
1: Below the bar
Relies on gut feeling and likability. Can't say what they screened for or how they compared candidates.
3: Meets the bar
Defines needed skills and uses a repeatable set of questions. Learns from a miss, but changes are small.
5: Above the bar
Sets criteria before sourcing, scores every candidate the same way, and cites a specific process change from a past miss.
Deal strategy
Plans how to win a specific deal by mapping buyers, risks, and next steps.
Questions
- Tell me about a large deal you helped win. What was the plan?
- Describe a time a deal stalled. What did you change?
- Tell me about a deal you chose to walk away from. Why?
1: Below the bar
Describes generic selling steps and relies on discounts or persistence. Can't name the buyers, the risks, or why they won or lost.
3: Meets the bar
Names the key buyers and main risks and sets clear next steps. Adjusts when stuck but reacts late or misses some stakeholders.
5: Above the bar
Maps every decision maker early, plans around risks, and adjusts fast. Explains clearly when a deal isn't worth pursuing.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.