Interview scorecard templates

Team Lead interview scorecard template

A first-time team lead is often promoted for doing the work well, which is a different job from leading it. This scorecard covers people management, coaching, delivery, prioritization and conflict resolution.

Customize this scorecard

Free to use. Nothing you type on the scorecard is saved.

Interview scorecard

Team Lead

Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.

People management

Sets clear expectations, gives regular feedback, and keeps team members accountable and supported day to day.

Score for People management

Questions

  • Tell me about a time you set expectations for someone new to your team.
  • Describe a time you gave hard feedback to a team member. What happened afterward?
  • Tell me about a time a team member's workload or morale was suffering. What did you do?

1: Below the bar

Gives vague expectations and avoids hard conversations. Notices problems late and blames the person instead of acting.

3: Meets the bar

Sets clear expectations and gives feedback when needed. Handles workload or morale issues once they are raised.

5: Above the bar

Sets expectations early, gives timely honest feedback, and spots workload or morale issues before they grow. Describes the results.

Coaching

Helps team members build their own skills through feedback, questions, and practice rather than giving answers.

Score for Coaching

Questions

  • Tell me about a time you helped someone improve a specific skill. What did you do?
  • Describe a time you gave hard feedback. How did the person respond afterward?
  • Tell me about a time coaching didn't work. What would you change?

1: Below the bar

Tells people the answer or does the work for them. Cannot describe any skill someone actually gained.

3: Meets the bar

Gives clear feedback and some guidance on a real skill gap. Shows a result but relies mostly on telling.

5: Above the bar

Asks questions so the person finds the answer, adapts to their style, and tracks progress. Shares what failed and what changed.

Delivery

Gets team work finished on time by tracking progress, removing blockers, and communicating risks early.

Score for Delivery

Questions

  • Tell me about a project your team delivered. How did you keep it on track?
  • Tell me about a time work was falling behind. What did you do?
  • Tell me about a time you delivered less than promised. What happened afterward?

1: Below the bar

Describes outcomes without saying what they did. Blames others for delays and shares risks only after deadlines pass.

3: Meets the bar

Tracks progress regularly and acts when work slips. Tells stakeholders about delays, though sometimes later than ideal.

5: Above the bar

Spots risks early, clears blockers, and resets expectations before deadlines. Explains what changed in how the team works afterward.

Prioritization

Ranks competing work by impact and deadlines, and explains trade-offs to the team and stakeholders.

Score for Prioritization

Questions

  • Tell me about a time your team had more work than capacity. What did you do?
  • Describe a time you said no or not yet to a request. How did you decide?
  • Tell me about a time priorities changed midway. How did you handle the work already underway?

1: Below the bar

Treats everything as urgent or takes the loudest request first. Can't explain why one task came before another.

3: Meets the bar

Ranks work using clear criteria like deadlines or impact. Tells the team the order but sometimes explains trade-offs late.

5: Above the bar

Sets criteria up front, says no with reasons, and tells affected people early. Revisits the ranking when facts change.

Conflict resolution

Addresses disagreements on the team early, listens to each side, and reaches an outcome people accept.

Score for Conflict resolution

Questions

  • Tell me about a time two people on your team clashed. What did you do?
  • Describe a disagreement you had with a peer or manager. How did it end?
  • Tell me about a conflict you could not fully resolve. What did you do afterward?

1: Below the bar

Avoids the conflict or picks a side quickly. Blames individuals and cannot say what happened afterward.

3: Meets the bar

Steps in, hears both sides, and finds a workable outcome. Follows up once but may wait until tension builds.

5: Above the bar

Spots tension early, separates facts from feelings, and gets both sides to agree on a fix. Checks later that it held.

Overall recommendation

Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.

Overall recommendation

Use this scorecard in PontaHR

With PontaHR, your team fills out scorecards on the candidate's profile. Compare ratings and feedback side by side when it's time to decide.

See how scorecards work in PontaHR, then try it with a guided free trial.

More interview scorecard templates

Hiring for a different role? Make your own scorecard