Interview scorecard
HR Manager
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
Employee relations
Handles employee conflicts and complaints fairly, listening to all sides and keeping working relationships intact.
Questions
- Tell me about a conflict between two employees you helped resolve. What did you do first?
- Describe a time an employee complained about their manager. How did you handle it?
- Tell me about a time you had to deliver unwelcome news to an employee.
1: Below the bar
Takes the first account as fact or avoids the conflict. Focuses on rules and ignores how people feel.
3: Meets the bar
Listens to both sides and follows a fair process. Resolves the issue but gives little thought to the ongoing relationship.
5: Above the bar
Hears everyone, stays neutral, and agrees clear next steps. Checks back later and shows how the relationships recovered.
HR knowledge
Applies employment law and HR good practice to everyday people decisions in a small company.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you applied employment law to a real decision. What did you do?
- How do you keep up with changes in employment rules? Give a recent example.
- Tell me about a time you were unsure of the rules. What did you do next?
1: Below the bar
Gives general or outdated answers. Cannot name the rules behind a decision or says they would just ask a lawyer.
3: Meets the bar
Names the relevant rules and applies them correctly to routine cases. Knows when to seek outside legal advice.
5: Above the bar
Cites specific rules and applies them to messy cases. Shows a regular habit of updating knowledge and spots risks early.
Discretion
Protects confidential information while still sharing what others need to act, and explains why.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you held confidential information others wanted. How did you handle it?
- Describe a time you had to share sensitive details with someone. How did you decide how much?
- Tell me about a time you realized you'd shared too much or too little. What did you do?
1: Below the bar
Shares confidential details casually or names people in examples. Has no clear rule for what to keep private.
3: Meets the bar
Keeps confidences and shares only with those who need to know. Handles pressure to share, but the reasoning is basic.
5: Above the bar
Sets clear limits up front, shares the minimum needed, and stays firm under pressure. Owns past slips and shows what they changed.
Problem solving
Finds the root cause of a people problem and chooses a practical fix that works.
Questions
- Tell me about a people problem that kept coming back. How did you find the cause?
- Describe a time you had to fix something with little information. What did you do?
- Tell me about a fix that didn't work. What did you change afterward?
1: Below the bar
Treats the visible symptom and stops there. Can't explain why the fix was chosen or whether it worked.
3: Meets the bar
Gathers some facts, finds a likely cause and picks a sensible fix. Checks the result only when asked.
5: Above the bar
Tests several possible causes, picks the fix by weighing options, then checks the result and adjusts without being prompted.
Process design
Builds simple, repeatable HR processes that people follow and that are improved over time.
Questions
- Tell me about an HR process you built or rebuilt. What problem did it solve?
- How did you get managers and staff to actually follow the new process?
- Tell me about a process that didn't work. How did you find out and fix it?
1: Below the bar
Describes tasks done ad hoc or copied from elsewhere. Can't say what problem the process solved or how it was checked.
3: Meets the bar
Built a clear process with steps and owners. Gathered some feedback and adjusted it when problems appeared.
5: Above the bar
Starts from the real problem, keeps steps minimal, gets users involved early, and tracks results to improve it.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.