Interview scorecard
Recruiter
Score each skill from 1 to 5. A 1 is below the bar for this role, a 3 meets it, and a 5 is above it. The examples show what each sounds like. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall in between.
Sourcing
Finds and reaches qualified candidates beyond job board applicants, using varied channels and tailored outreach.
Questions
- Tell me about a hard role you filled. Where did you look for candidates?
- Tell me about an outreach message that got a reply. What did you write?
- Tell me about a time a sourcing channel stopped working. What did you change?
1: Below the bar
Relies on job postings and inbound applicants. Can't name where good candidates came from or why outreach worked.
3: Meets the bar
Uses two or three channels beyond job boards and personalizes outreach. Tracks replies but adjusts only when a search stalls.
5: Above the bar
Picks channels based on where the target candidates are, tests message changes, and shows response numbers that shaped their next search.
Candidate assessment
Judges candidates against clear job criteria using evidence from screens, not impressions.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you screened a candidate who looked weak on paper. What did you do?
- How do you decide what to ask in a first screening call?
- Tell me about a time your read on a candidate was wrong. What happened?
1: Below the bar
Relies on gut feel or CV keywords. Can't say what evidence supported a decision or what the role needed.
3: Meets the bar
Screens against the job requirements and records reasons for each decision. Sometimes lets first impressions or one answer sway the result.
5: Above the bar
Defines criteria with the hiring manager first, asks the same core questions, and backs each decision with evidence. Checks their own bias and learns from misses.
Stakeholder management
Aligns hiring managers on role needs and keeps them informed, even when expectations clash with the market.
Questions
- Tell me about a time a hiring manager's expectations for a role were unrealistic. What did you do?
- Describe how you keep a busy hiring manager updated during an open search.
- Tell me about a time you disagreed with a manager about a candidate. How did it end?
1: Below the bar
Accepts every request without pushback or avoids hard conversations. Updates only when asked, and blames managers when searches stall.
3: Meets the bar
Raises concerns with managers and gives regular updates. Uses some market evidence but needs a nudge to settle disagreements.
5: Above the bar
Opens with a clear brief, uses market data to reset expectations, and sends steady updates. Resolves disagreements and keeps the manager's trust.
Candidate experience
Keeps candidates informed, respected and clear about next steps from first contact to final outcome.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you kept a candidate engaged through a long hiring process.
- Tell me about delivering a rejection. How did you handle it and what happened next?
- Tell me about a time a candidate had a bad experience in your process. What did you do?
1: Below the bar
Treats updates and rejections as optional. Blames candidates for lost interest and describes no steps to fix a bad experience.
3: Meets the bar
Gives regular updates, sets expectations on timing and sends rejections promptly. Fixes problems when candidates raise them.
5: Above the bar
Anticipates candidate worries, personalizes updates and gives useful rejection feedback. Spots process gaps, fixes them and checks candidate feedback.
Organization
Tracks many open roles and candidates so nothing slips and every next step has an owner.
Questions
- Tell me about a time you ran many open roles at once. How did you keep track?
- Describe a time a deadline or interview slot nearly slipped. What did you do?
- How do you decide what to work on first in a busy week?
1: Below the bar
Relies on memory or scattered notes. Describes missed follow-ups and reacts only when someone chases.
3: Meets the bar
Uses a clear system like a tracker or calendar. Keeps most roles on schedule and recovers when something slips.
5: Above the bar
Describes a consistent system, ranks work by urgency, and spots delays early. Gives an example of a fix they kept.
Overall recommendation
Decide on your own, before you compare notes with the rest of the panel.